7 Signs Your IT Company is Failing You

Most business owners can’t tell if their IT provider is actually doing a good job until something breaks.

Today I’ll walk you through 7 signs that your IT company is falling short. From vague answers and recurring problems to unclear response times and no visibility into what you’re paying for.

None of these require technical knowledge to spot. You just need to know what to look for.

#1 – Your provider tends to be reactive

Your provider tends to be reactive and not proactive. What I mean by this is that you only ever hear from them when something breaks or, even worse than that, you’re the one who has to contact them to tell them something has stopped working.

There could be several reasons for this, but the most common is that they either have too many clients on board or are trying to put out too many fires at once. And in that situation, it’s almost always the biggest customer that’s going to get the most attention. Now, I should stress that if you are in a position where you are having to contact your service provider to tell them something is wrong – something that they should be monitoring proactively, that’s a serious concern and they need to be giving you a very good reason as to why that’s the case.

#2 – Vague or hollow answers

Prior to working as an IT consultant, I used to work for a business that was IT focused to the point we used to take a client’s data, process it, and put it back online. To do this, we relied on a third-party IT provider and I would be very concerned about backups as I’d had hard drives that had failed time and time again. Because of this I would be calling them up and asking, “Look, are we backed up properly?” And all I’d get in response was, “Yeah, we’re all covered. Don’t worry about it,” until, of course, that one morning when I started getting phone calls saying that users couldn’t access our systems.

The reason IT providers say “Yeah, it’s all good.” is that It’s much easier to do than to actually go away and check things. Equally, it could just be a situation where the person you’re asking doesn’t know the answer, and they’re just trying to give you the answer that you want to hear.

In an ideal world, what you should expect is a detailed response. When I had a problem with my backups, I should have been able to ask the question and get a response that included the last time a backup was completed, the last time one was restored or I should have been offered a walk-through of their process.

#3 – The same problems keep coming back

This one has to be one of the biggest annoyances for a business owner. And a common example of this is that your internet access goes down. You call up your provider and they ask you to reboot your router. You do this and, presto, the internet comes back up. A few weeks later, of course, the same issue happens again. Internet goes down. You call up the provider, and they offer the same resolution.

Now, when this happens, basically you’re getting your symptoms fixed and not the root cause fixed. And that’s not necessarily a problem. At the end of the day, you’re calling up a help desk and they are there for one reason and that is to get you back up and running as soon as possible. However, what you really want is a permanent resolution. Even if it’s an inconvenient truth, like we need to upgrade your router or it’s going to take a little bit of downtime, a permanent fix will often save you money in the long run.

#4 – Not being able to reach your IT support

A lot of providers today use online portals for requesting changes and logging faults. There’s no two ways about it, this is an incredibly convenient way to run a business. But it can feel less accountable, especially when they respond within 10 minutes one day and take 2 or 3 days the next time a fault is logged.

The issue here is that it often indicates you don’t have a clearly defined Service Level Agreement (SLA), which means that you are just getting service on a best-effort basis. What you want is a guaranteed written response time tied to a severity, with some form of accountability that, if that response time is missed, you’ll get some kind of compensation.

#5 – You don’t know what you’re paying for

This can happen when you get a one-line invoice every month, no breakdown or detail around what’s actually included.

To give you a real-world example, I was working for a client that had a fully managed service, and they were having issues with unexpected charges from their provider. I asked the managed service provider what their fully managed service product included. They said the client doesn’t actually have a fully managed service, which is why they were being billed for these additional charges.

This often happens because many providers sell bundled service because it’s easier to sell a package than it is to sell the individual service.

The problem is that over a period of say, a year, you forget exactly what is within your package and you start making assumptions. You might assume upgrades are included in a monitored and maintained service, whereas the provider only considers them part of their fully managed service.

What you want is a breakdown of all of the services that you are getting, with a price associated with them. That way you actually have an idea of where your costs are going and what services you’re paying for.

#6 – They own your systems more than you do

This is where you don’t have any login to your own equipment. I should be clear here. I’m referring to equipment that you have bought and paid for. If it’s your IT provider’s equipment, that’s fair enough. However, all too often I see situations where a client starts a new IT project, the provider buys the hardware on the clients’ behalf, they design, configure and maintain it, but they don’t give the customer a single login.

This means you can’t go in there and check anything or make changes. The reason this tends to happen is a retention tactic as It makes your life harder to move your business elsewhere.

A really good provider on the other hand, will make sure that you can login to the system and they will give you full documentation. That way, you can do whatever you want.

At the end of the day, if you go in there and you make a mess of it, they can charge you to fix it.

#7 – They always blame someone else

A lot of IT providers are actually customers of other IT service providers. As an example, let’s say you purchase a wide area network service from your IT provider and they ask “would you like to purchase an internet breakout service?” If the price looks good, why would they not manage your wide area network and your internet at the same time?

The problem is they don’t go into detail about their internet service, which may rely on a single Internet Service Provider (ISP). If there is a fault in the ISP’s network, you will have no internet. Your IT provider then blames the ISP. And to be fair to them, they’re not actually lying.

If the ISP has a fault they have a fault. But it’s not the fundamental problem with the service. The fundamental problem is that they are relying on a single ISP. This tends to happen because it’s far easier to point the finger and blame the ISP rather than disclose any limitations within their infrastructure.

The 7 signs

If two or more of these signs sound familiar, it’s not necessarily time to switch providers — but it is worth a closer look:

  • They’re always reactive, never proactive
  • You get vague answers to specific questions
  • The same problem keeps coming back
  • Response times are inconsistent or unclear
  • You don’t know what you’re actually paying for
  • They own your systems more than you do
  • They always blame someone else

Book your 15-minute independent second opinion

Let's take a look together

If you would like an honest review of what you’re currently paying for, use the link below:

Related Videos

Am I Overpaying for IT Support? Here’s How to Actually Know

There's no single "normal" price for IT support. Here's the process to find out if you're overpaying — 3 patterns to watch for.
What is an SLA, and Does Yours Actually Protect You?

What is an SLA, and Does Yours Actually Protect You?

Most business owners have never read their IT provider's SLA. Here's what it should include, in plain English, and a 2-minute check to see if yours is real.
7 Signs Your IT Company is Failing You

7 Signs Your IT Company is Failing You

Not sure if your IT provider is doing a good job? Here are 7 signs your IT company might be failing you — and what good support looks like instead.